Best Ice Cream in Montauk, NY

Best Ice Cream in Montauk, NY

Montauk’s charming and serene village, at the east end of Long Island and New York State, is often referred to as “The End.” Indulge in the beautiful beaches or try fishing here, but don’t miss out on the best ice cream in Montauk.

Best Ice Cream in Montauk, NY

Best Ice Cream Spots in Montauk

Merely 120 miles from New York City, you’ll see a world of difference in this remote beach town.A re you craving some delicious homemade ice cream, banana splits, soft serve, or ice cream cakes? You’ll find it all and more in Montauk’s best ice cream shops.

Ralph’s Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream

If you’re looking for some of the best desserts in Montauk, Ralph’s is the place to visit. Located on the island’s east end, this Staten Island-born chain has been dispensing ice cream and Italian ices in 100+ flavors since 1970.

The different flavors of ice cream that you can pick include Black Cherry Vanilla, Blueberry Cheesecake, Cotton Candy, and Mississippi Mud. 

They also serve their famous ices in over 100 flavors, apart from ice cream sandwiches, soft serve ice cream, and some sumptuous snacks.

However, the stars of Ralph’s are their mouthwatering signature sundaes. One look at the Peanut Butter Crunch sundae, and you’ll be drooling before you realize it. Vanilla ice cream with PB sauce, PB cups, and chocolate crunch, with some delectable toppings; I wouldn’t be surprised if you went for a second helping.

Don’t miss out on the Twisters; it’s any flavor of Ralph’s Italian Ice layered between soft ice cream. This is your chance to try your favorite ice cream and Italian Ice flavors in one go.

Fudge N Stuff

This Willy Wonka-style sweet shop is a great place to satisfy your sweet cravings. Fudge N Stuff has been serving fresh homemade fudge and chocolates every day for over 35 years.

The eye-popping assortment of old-fashioned penny candy, gourmet jellybeans, lollipops, nuts, hot popcorn, and chocolate-covered pretzels will have your inner child jumping with joy. 

While each of their 30 different flavors of fudge is to die for, they also have equally good ice cream. Take your pick from soft ice cream, sundaes, banana splits, malts, hot chocolate, or a cappuccino; you won’t be disappointed.

Want to take your taste buds on a roller coaster ride? Try some ice cream paired with a giant chunk of fudge. My recommendation is chocolate ice cream with Rainbow Cookie or Rocky Road fudge.

The Candied Anchor

Located in the heart of Montauk, at 721 Main Street, is the sweet shop of the 1950s – The Candied Anchor. The place is classic Americana!

While it’s a great spot to grab all the candy you could possibly want, there are also quirky retro gifts, baked confections, party supplies, and of course, ice cream.

Stepping into The Candied Anchor will bring a nostalgic feel; you can find your favorite childhood candy apart from the new locally-made treats. Grab some amazing candy and pair it with equally delightful ice cream to satisfy your sweet tooth.

The best part is they also have Mochi ice cream, and that’s the cherry on top for me.

John’s Drive-In

Stop by John’s Drive-In in Montauk if you’re hunting for some good food and delicious homemade ice cream. This iconic ice cream shop has been a Montauk staple since 1967.

While you can fill up on their scrumptious burgers, sandwiches, wraps, and finger foods, don’t forget to save some space for desserts!

They have a rotating selection of homemade flavors apart from sorbet and soft-serve ice cream. You can get your favorite flavor in their ice cream cones or turn it into sundaes, shakes, and even cakes.

Their signature ice cream flavors include Black Raspberry, Mint Chip, and Cookie Dough, plus don’t miss out on their Oreo Cookie Ice cream sandwiches!

Ice Cream Cottage

Technically, the Ice Cream Cottage is located on Montauk Highway in historic Mastic, not in Montauk. But, this ice cream shop managed to crawl into this list owing to their amazing super-premium ice cream.

They’ve been serving some excellent ice cream around Montauk since they opened their doors in 1990. Since then, they’ve also won multiple awards, including the Best Ice Cream Cone on Long Island award in the summer of 2016.

Among their hard ice cream flavors, some unique ones include Bartman, PB&J, Mastic Mash, and Cannoli Cream, Think Watermelon, Strawberry Kiwi, Purple Cow, Pina Colada, Mastic Beach Berry, Egg Nog, Cantaloupe, and Hocus Pocus.

The one you absolutely mustn’t miss is the world-famous Chocolate Overdose, voted the Best Chocolate Ice Cream in 2012.

They also have some lovely ice cream cakes; get yours if you’re celebrating a special occasion.

  • Ice Cream Cottage, 1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic. NY 11950

Other Places With Delicious Ice Cream in the Hamptons

Here are some other places you can find good ice cream around Montauk:

The cherry on top!

Call it “The Hampton Without Crowds” or “The Surf Fishing Capital of the World,” there’s no denying that the best ice cream in Montauk will satisfy your sugar cravings and cool you off on a hot summer day.

Whether you’re in the mood for classic ice cream flavors or a hearty sundae, Montauk has something for everyone.

Traveling Elsewhere? Here Are Some Great Ice Cream Shops You Can Try!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *