Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati, Ohio

Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati, Ohio

Cincinnati, a city known for its rich history and vibrant culture, also boasts a delectable ice cream scene that’s sure to delight both locals and visitors alike. From traditional favorites to innovative flavors, there’s no shortage of options to satisfy your ice cream cravings. In this guide, I’ll take you on a journey through some of the best ice cream in Cincinnati!

Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati, Ohio

Best Places for Delicious Ice Cream in Cincinnati, Ohio

Cincinnati’s ice cream scene is a reflection of the city’s diverse and dynamic spirit. From the traditional charm of Graeter’s Ice Cream and Aglamesis Bros. to the artisanal delights of Hello Honey Ice Cream and the European flair of Eishaus, each ice cream parlor has something unique to offer. And let’s not forget the playful innovation of Creamy Whips, where you can let your creativity run wild.

Graeter’s Ice Cream

Graeter’s Ice Cream is a name synonymous with Cincinnati’s ice cream heritage. Established in 1870, this family-owned business has maintained its commitment to crafting small-batch ice cream using the French Pot process making small batches of only 2.5-gallon. This labor-intensive method ensures a rich and creamy texture that’s second to none.

With an array of flavors ranging from the classic Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip to the seasonal favorites like Pumpkin Spice, Graeter’s offers something for every palate. Don’t miss the chance to savor their signature “chocolate chips” – large, luscious pieces of chocolate that are handcrafted using a unique process that involves pouring melted chocolate into the ice cream during the final moments of freezing.

  • Graeter’s Ice Cream, 12704 Erie Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45208, United States. They also have other locations. Do check their website.

Aglamesis Bros.

Step into Aglamesis Bros., and you’ll be transported to a bygone era of classic ice cream parlors. Established two Greek brothers in 1908, this charming establishment is renowned for its commitment to tradition and quality. The parlor’s vintage décor, complete with ornate woodwork and old-fashioned soda fountains, adds to the nostalgic experience. You can still enter via their storefront, decorated with Tiffany lamps, Portuguese marble and lots and lots of pink.

Aglamesis Bros. offers an extensive selection of ice cream flavors and sundaes, all made with the finest ingredients and attention to detail. Their hot fudge sundae, topped with freshly whipped cream and a cherry, is a timeless treat that captures the essence of their legacy. Don’t miss their frosty pink “champagne Italian ice.”

  • Aglamesis Bros., 3046 Madison Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45209, United States

Hello Honey Ice Cream

For those seeking artisanal and unique flavors, Hello Honey Ice Cream is a must-visit. This locally-owned creamery prides itself on creating small-batch ice cream, made-from-scratch using high-quality ingredients sourced from local farmers and producers.

with totally unique flavor combos: banana honeycomb, sweet corn pecan, charcoal sesame, espresso fudge. Also make marshmallows in-house, which they can toast directly on top of your ice cream. Opening 4th location soon.

With flavors like banana honeycomb, sweet corn pecan, and charcoal sesame, Hello Honey pushes the boundaries of ice cream innovation. They also make marshmallows in-house, which they can toast directly on top of your ice cream. Their dedication to incorporating seasonal and regional ingredients ensures a fresh and exciting experience with every visit.


Although Eishaus has a German name, it is thoroughly American. They play on their heritage by serving “spaghetti eis,” a dish native to Germany where the ice cream is pushed through an extruder to turn into the shape of spaghetti. It is then topped with fruit, chocolate, and other delicious toppings.

You cannot miss the Spaghetti 3-ways playing on Cincinnati chili 3-way with spaghetti eis, chocolate sauce for the chili and shaved yellow chocolate for the cheddar cheese!!

  • Eishaus, 117 Park Pl, Covington, KY 41011, United States (Just over the bridge!)

Putz’s Creamy Whips: A Twist on Tradition

Putz’s Creamy Whips adds a playful twist to the classic soft-serve experience. Creamy Whips is the local term for a walk-up soft-serve ice cream shack open only during the summer months. T

Putz’s, open since 1938, is one of the most popular! Don’t be scared if you see something blue being served – it’s a Cincinnati traditions which is a mix between blueberry and cotton candy that originated at Kings Island in 1982 to promote the opening of a Smurfs ride!

Other Places in Cincinnati To Get Great Ice Cream:

The cherry on top!

Whether you’re a local seeking to satisfy your sweet tooth or a visitor eager to explore Cincinnati’s culinary landscape, these ice cream parlors promise an unforgettable experience.

Traveling Elsewhere? Here Are Some Great Ice Cream Shops You Can Try!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *