Key West is a paradise for sun-seekers, food lovers, and, of course, ice cream enthusiasts. Whether you’re strolling down Duval Street on a hot day or looking for the perfect treat after visiting one of the many Key West restaurants, there’s no shortage of options to satisfy your sweet tooth. From homemade ice cream made with the finest ingredients to innovative liquid nitrogen creations, these are the 10 best places to find ice cream dreams in the Florida Keys.
Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream
A hidden gem on Duval Street, Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream is known for its tropical flavors made in small batches. Their creamy texture and use of natural ingredients make every scoop a delight. Don’t leave without trying their famous key lime ice cream, a must-have treat that perfectly captures the taste of the Keys.
Find it here: 1105 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
Wicked Lick
For a truly unique ice cream experience, Wicked Lick uses liquid nitrogen to craft fresh, smooth, and ultra-creamy treats. Their rotating selection of new flavors means there’s always something exciting to try. Whether you crave classic favorites or bold, unexpected combinations, this sweet shop never disappoints.
Find it here: 335 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
Key West Polar Bear
This family-friendly ice cream shop is a local favorite, serving up homemade ice cream with a rich and creamy texture. The friendly staff ensures that every visit is a delightful experience. From key lime pie to dark chocolate indulgences, there’s a scoop for every taste bud here.
Find it here: 411 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
Mattheessen’s
Mattheessen’s is famous for its oversized cookies, but their homemade ice cream is just as legendary. Made with the finest ingredients, their ice cream pairs perfectly with their freshly baked treats. Try their signature key lime ice cream or mix it up with a scoop of their indulgent dark chocolate.
Find it here: 419 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
Rooster Treats Ice Cream & Mini Donuts
This charming spot in Key West offers a delightful combination of creamy ice cream and fresh mini donuts. Their handcrafted flavors, paired with warm, sugary donuts, make for a unique and indulgent treat. It’s a perfect stop for those exploring the island and craving something sweet.
Find it here: 1327 Simonton St, Key West
Kilwin’s
A staple for dessert lovers, Kilwin’s in Key West serves up rich, creamy ice cream alongside their famous handmade fudge and chocolates. The freshly made waffle cones add an extra layer of indulgence, making this a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Find it here: 505 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
Tropical Vibes Cones & Bowls
For a taste of the tropics, this vibrant Key West van offers a selection of soft serve, acai bowls, and fruit-packed treats. Their refreshing flavors, like mango and coconut, capture the essence of island life, making it an ideal spot for cooling down after a day in the sun.
Find it here: Higgs Beach, Key West
Now Try Phoenix’s Best Ice Cream Places
Like Tucson, Phoenix’s sweltering temperatures make ice cream more than just a treat—it’s a necessity. Fortunately, the city is home to a variety of incredible ice cream shops, each offering unique flavors and experiences.